oldoldoldoldnew

oldoldoldoldnew

accidental diary entry 18/03/2023

On Cioran

Philip Traylen's avatar
Philip Traylen
Mar 18, 2023
∙ Paid

Cioran said something along the lines of: I would have killed myself if I didn’t have the option of contemplating it. Possibly Kafka, too, and possibly Nietzsche. Sensible people.

Dostoevsky, no. Dostoevsky couldn’t think about it because then he would have done it – I remember that line from William Carlos Williams:

The suicide is the perfect type of the man of action (again, perhaps misquoting slightly. To prove that I refuse to Google it).

I can’t contemplate it, though.

It only comes out – and quite easily – when I write, and I do feel slightly refreshed afterwards.

Christians stared at skulls, after all.

But this activity makes even more sense in a non-Christian context, and yet it is not widely promoted.

As if secular society abandoned death along with religion, or failed to effectively distinguish the two.

Maybe a Freud-style argument works here, with suicide much like incest: you have to discourage it or else…

The only difference is that suicide is treated as tragedy, while incest is…

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Philip Traylen.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Philip Traylen · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture